Close Alert Banner
Skip to Content
I Want To
  • Pay my Invoice
  • Register for an Event
  • Join a Committee
  • Become a Member
  • Resolutions
  • OACP Board of Directors
  • Contact My Police Service
  • Be a Police Officer
  • Be a Special Constable
Mobile Log In
  • Member
  • Committee
  • PCPG
Log In
  • Member
  • Committee
  • PCPG

Ontario Association of Chiefs of Police Logo Ontario Association of Chiefs of Police Logo Print

Contact Us
  • About Us

    Who We Are

    • About OACP
    • Board of Directors
    • Governance and Constitution
    • Membership
    • Past Presidents
    • Staff
    • Strategic Plan
    • Vision and Mission
    • Zones

    What We Do

    • Advocacy
    • Association Partners
    • Business-to-Business (B2B)
    • Education Partners
    • OACP Annual Awards
    • 2023 Annual Award Winners!
    • OACP Contact
    • Ontario Police Organizations
    • Partnership Opportunities
    • Resolutions
    • Vendors
  • Current Issues
    • News
    • Resource Documents
    • Police Governance
    • Cost of Policing
    • Sustainable Funding of Policing Services
    • Threat to “Positive Funding”
    • Mental Health
    • WSIB Reform
    • Pre-charge Consultation and Justice Reform
    • Decriminalizing Illegal Substances
    • Downloading of Service Responsibilities to Police
    • Systemic Racism and Implicit Bias in Policing
    • Leadership/Mentoring Challenges
    • SWOP/Modernization of Discipline System
  • Committees
    • Committee Overview
    • List of Committees
    • Working Groups
    • FAQ
    • Respectful Workplaces in Policing Working Group
  • Events & Professional
    Development

    OACP Events

    • Events Calendar
    • Commemorative Dates
    • 2024 Annual Conference Photo Gallery
    • 2025 Annual Conference
    • 2025 Police EA Professional Development Symposium
    • 2025 Reintegration Facilitator Course

    Professional Development

    • Certified Municipal Manager Program
    • Educational Courses
    • Police CEO Day
    • Rotman Police Leadership Program
    • OACP and OnStar Beyond the Badge Award
  • Public Safety
    & Awareness
    • Public Education Campaigns
    • Get Support: Kids Help Phone
    • Mass Marketing Fraud Campaign
    • Journal of Community Safety and Well-Being
    • Out of the Shadows Resource Document
    • Military Veterans Wellness Program
  • Careers
    In Policing
    • Constable Selection System
    • Discover Policing
    • OACP Certificate
    • Professional Opportunities

Assessing the Performance of the Chief of Police

  • Open new window to share this page via Facebook Facebook
  • Open new window to share this page via Twitter Twitter
  • Open new window to share this page via LinkedIn LinkedIn
  • Email this page Email
  • Quick Links
  • Vision and Mission
  • Executives and directors
  • Constitution
  • History
Email icon Back to Search

                                    

 

Assessing the Performance of the Chief of Police – The Facts

 

The delivery of effective and accountable policing services to the people of Ontario is vital to the overall safety and well-being of everyone who makes Ontario their home. Every person in our province has a right to feel that they, their loved ones, colleagues, and neighbours live and work in safe communities. To that end, public safety depends on police professionals who are ultimately accountable and dedicated to serving their fellow Ontarians.

Critical to effective and accountable policing services is the Chief of Police. Whether they oversee large or small organizations, services that police a municipality, a group of municipalities or a region or in urban or rural settings, Chiefs are required to provide the leadership needed to ensure their members are well-equipped and supported in performing their duties. The accountability of the Chief of Police is an important component in ensuring public accountability. In this regard, police services board (on behalf of the community) have a vital role in assessing the performance of the Chief.

In public comments made by a police association leader, it was suggested that a police association is in the best position to assess the performance of the Chief of Police. While police associations play an important role in labour relations and in the representation of their members, it needs to be clearly understood that police services boards have both the legal jurisdiction and the public mandate to direct Chiefs of Police and monitor their performance.

In accordance with section 31(1) of the Police Services Act (PSA), police services boards are responsible for the provision of adequate and effective policing within their respective communities. A board’s statutory responsibilities include:

  • Establishing policies for the effective management of the police service,
  • Recruiting and appointing the Chief of Police and any deputy chief of police, and
  • Directing the Chief of Police and monitoring his or her performance.

Boards play an important role in maintaining, in the words of Sir Robert Peel, “the historic tradition that the police are the public and that the public are the police.”  They embody the public’s oversight of a police service with board members appointed in equal number from the duly elected regional or municipal council and by the province, plus one community member chosen by the council [PSA, s.33].

Boards consult and work with members of the public, through the development of their business plans [O. Reg. 3/99, s.30] and in their participation in the preparation of municipal community safety and well-being plans [PSA, s.145(1)7.]

It is the duty of the Chief of Police to administer and oversee the operations of the police service in accordance with the objectives, priorities, and policies established by the board [PSA, s.41(1)(a).]  They must also ensure that members of the police service carry out their duties lawfully and in a manner that reflects the needs of the community, and that discipline is maintained within the police service [PSA, s.41(1)(b)] 

The foundation of any police service rests on two important pillars:

  1. The members who serve under the Chief’s command,

   2. The community that they all serve. 

Both pillars are equally deserving of a voice. As public scrutiny of policing continues to grow, Chiefs of Police are expected to be agents of change. In turn, Chiefs are counting on police services boards to provide effective governance and to assess the Chief’s performance in accordance with the law and their communities’ needs.

The experiences and views of police service members are important to the overall well-being and effectiveness of a police organization. Every Chief of Police endeavours to engage with members at many levels – on the job, through their engagement with the police services boards, in their internal communication to members, in the community, etc. Healthy, effective police workplaces require every member to do their absolute best to serve the public and support their fellow police service members.

The best way to address issues in the police workplace is clear and honest dialogue between senior management and frontline members. Police associations are an important partner in this, as are police service boards.

Police boards have clear responsibilities, among which are the exclusive responsibility to assess the performance of the Chief of Police. Police associations should be in constant dialogue with the Chief and senior management on issues that are important to their members. However, it must be reiterated that it is a legislative fact that Boards have the legal jurisdiction and the public mandate to assess the Chief’s performance. 

There are significant challenges (and opportunities) facing policing. The public is clear that they expect to see effective, accountable police services that meet the changing realities and needs of the communities they serve. They expect the public’s significant investments in policing to deliver community safety and well-being to all members of the community, in a transparent and respectful manner.

It is time that all police actors – police services boards, senior managers, police associations – commit to honest dialogue, positive change, and collaboration in relation to their common goal of serving the public and supporting police personnel in accomplishing their important task during challenging times.

 

                                                                                      

Chief Jim MacSween                                                                            Patrick Weaver 

President, Ontario Association of Chiefs of Police                         Chair, Ontario Association of Police Services Boards

 

Email iconSubscribe

Current Issues

    • News
    • Resource Documents
    • Police Governance
    • Cost of Policing
    • Sustainable Funding of Policing Services
    • Threat to “Positive Funding”
    • Mental Health
    • WSIB Reform
    • Pre-charge Consultation and Justice Reform
    • Decriminalizing Illegal Substances
    • Downloading of Service Responsibilities to Police
    • Systemic Racism and Implicit Bias in Policing
    • Leadership/Mentoring Challenges
    • SWOP/Modernization of Discipline System

Contact Us

Stay up-to-date

Subscribe to this page to get notified when this page has updated content.

Ontario Association of Chiefs of Police Footer Logo

Contact us

  • Phone 416-926-0424
  • Toll Free 1-800-816-1767
  • Fax 416-926-0436
  • E-mail us

Corporate office

40 College Street
Suite 605
Toronto ON
M5G 2J3

Website

  • About Us
  • Current Issues
  • Committees
  • Events & Professional Development
  • Public Safety and Awareness
  • Careers in Policing

Other Links

  • Website Feedback
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy Policy
  • Subscribe
Top
View our Facebook Page View our YouTube Page View our Instagram Page

Copyright 2020 OACP

By GHD Digital

What are you looking for?

Close Old Browser Notification
Browser Compatibility Notification
It appears you are trying to access this site using an outdated browser. As a result, parts of the site may not function properly for you. We recommend updating your browser to its most recent version at your earliest convenience.